Assessing the feasibility and acceptability of a financial versus behavioural incentive-based intervention for community health workers in rural Indonesia

Gadsden T., Jan S., Sujarwoto S., Kusumo B.E., Palagyi A.

The George Institute for Global Health, University of New South Wales, Sydney, Australia; Faculty of Medicine and Health, The University of Sydney School of Public Health, Sydney, Australia; Department of Public Administration, University of Brawijaya, Malang, Indonesia


Abstract

Background: The World Health Organization recommends that community health workers (CHWs) receive a mix of financial and non-financial incentives, yet notes that there is limited evidence to support the use of one type of incentive (i.e. financial or non-financial) over another. In preparation for a larger scale trial, we investigated the acceptability and feasibility of two different forms of incentives for CHWs in Malang District, Indonesia. Methods: CHWs working on a cardiovascular disease (CVD) risk screening and management programme in two villages were assigned to receive either a financial or non-financial incentive for 6 months. In the financial incentives village, CHWs (n = 20) received 16,000 IDR (USD 1.1) per patient followed up or 500,000 IDR (USD 34.1) if they followed up 100% of their assigned high-risk CVD patients each month. In the non-financial incentive village, CHWs (n = 20) were eligible to receive a Quality Care Certificate for following up the highest number of high-risk CVD patients each month, awarded in a public ceremony. At the end of the 6-month intervention period, focus group discussions were conducted with CHWs and semi-structured interviews with programme administrators to investigate acceptability, facilitators and barriers to implementation and feasibility of the incentive models. Data on monthly CHW follow-up activity were analysed using descriptive statistics to assess the preliminary impact of each incentive on service delivery outcomes, and CHW motivation levels were assessed pre- and post-implementation. Results: Factors beyond the control of the study significantly interrupted the implementation of the financial incentive, particularly the threat of violence towards CHWs due to village government elections. Despite CHWs reporting that both the financial and non-financial incentives were acceptable, programme administrators questioned the sustainability of the non-financial incentive and reported CHWs were ambivalent towards them. CHW service delivery outcomes increased 17% for CHWs eligible for the non-financial incentive and 21% for CHWs eligible for the financial incentive. There was a statistically significant increase (p < 0.0001) in motivation scores for the performance domain in both villages. Conclusion: It was feasible to deliver both a performance-based financial and non-financial incentive to CHWs in Malang District, Indonesia, and both incentive types were acceptable to CHWs and programme administrators. Evidence of preliminary effectiveness also suggests that both the financial and non-financial incentives were associated with improved motivation and service delivery outcomes. These findings will inform the next phase of incentive design, in which incentive feasibility and preliminary effectiveness will need to be considered alongside their longer-term sustainability within the health system. © 2021, The Author(s). Community health workers; Incentives; Indonesia; Motivation; Performance


Journal

Pilot and Feasibility Studies

Publisher: BioMed Central Ltd

Volume 7, Issue 1, Art No 132, Page – , Page Count


Journal Link: https://www.scopus.com/inward/record.uri?eid=2-s2.0-85108840329&doi=10.1186%2fs40814-021-00871-7&partnerID=40&md5=4b72e97fa5e457b3131f031340576536

doi: 10.1186/s40814-021-00871-7

Issn: 20555784

Type: All Open Access, Gold, Green


References

Rowe, A.K., Labadie, G., Jackson, D., Vivas-Torrealba, C., Simon, J., Improving health worker performance: an ongoing challenge for meeting the sustainable development goals (2018) BMJ, 362; Darzi, A., Evans, T., The global shortage of health workers – an opportunity to transform care (2016) Lancet, 388 (10060), pp. P2576-P2577; Lehmann, U., Sanders, D., (2007) Community health workers: what do we know about them? the state of the evidence on programmes, activities, costs an impact on health outcomes of using community health workers, p. 42. , World Health Organization, Geneva; Schaaf, M., Warthin, C., Freedman, L., Topp, S.M., The community health worker as service extender, cultural broker and social change agent: a critical interpretive synthesis of roles, intent and accountability (2020) BMJ Glob Health, 5 (6); Glenton, C., Scheel, I.B., Lewin, S., Swingler, G.H., Can lay health workers increase the uptake of childhood immunisation? Systematic review and typology (2011) Tropical Med Int Health, 16 (9), pp. 1044-1053; Lewin, S., Munabi-Babigumira, S., Glenton, C., Daniels, K., Bosch-Capblanch, X., van Wyk, B.E., Odgaard-Jensen, J., Zwarenstein, M., Lay health workers in primary and community health care for maternal and child health and the management of infectious diseases (2010) Cochrane Database Syst Rev, 3; Lassi, Z.S., Bhutta, Z.A., (2015) Community-Based Intervention Packages for Reducing Maternal and Neonatal Morbidity and Mortality and Improving Neonatal Outcomes, 3. , Cochrane Database Syst Rev; Kok, M.C., Dieleman, M., Taegtmeyer, M., Broerse, J.E., Kane, S.S., Ormel, H., Tijm, M.M., de Koning, K.A., Which intervention design factors influence performance of community health workers in low- and middle-income countries? A systematic review (2015) Health Policy Plan, 30 (9), pp. 1207-1227; Glenton, C., Colvin, C.J., Carlsen, B., Swartz, A., Lewin, S., Noyes, J., Rashidian, A., Barriers and facilitators to the implementation of lay health worker programmes to improve access to maternal and child health: qualitative evidence synthesis (2013) Cochrane Database Syst Rev, 10; Bhutta, Z., Lassi, Z., Pariyo, G., Huicho, L., (2009) Global experience of community health workers for delivery of health related millenium development goals: a systematic review, country case studies, and recommendations for integration into national health systems, , Global Health Workforce Alliance, World Health Organization; Pallas, S.W., Minhas, D., Pérez-Escamilla, R., Taylor, L., Curry, L., Bradley, E.H., Community health workers in low- and middle-income countries: what do we know about scaling up and sustainability? (2013) Am J Public Health, 103 (7), pp. e74-e82; Scott, K., Beckham, S.W., Gross, M., Pariyo, G., Rao, K.D., Cometto, G., Perry, H.B., What do we know about community-based health worker programs? A systematic review of existing reviews on community health workers (2018) Hum Resour Health, 16 (1), p. 39; Agarwal, S., Kirk, K., Sripad, P., Bellows, B., Abuya, T., Warren, C., Setting the global research agenda for community health systems: literature and consultative review (2019) Hum Resour Health, 17 (1), p. 22; (2018) WHO guideline on health policy and system support to optimize community health worker programmes, , WHO, Geneva; Kok, M.C., Kane, S.S., Tulloch, O., Ormel, H., Theobald, S., Dieleman, M., Taegtmeyer, M., de Koning, K.A., How does context influence performance of community health workers in low- and middle-income countries? Evidence from the literature (2015) Health Res Policy Syst, 13 (1), p. 13; Miller, G., Babiarz, K.S., (2013) Pay-for-performance incentives in low- and middle-income country health programs, , NBER Working Paper 18932; George, A.S., LeFevre, A.E., Schleiff, M., Mancuso, A., Sacks, E., Sarriot, E., Hubris, humility and humanity: expanding evidence approaches for improving and sustaining community health programmes (2018) BMJ Glob Health, 3 (3); Lagarde, M., Huicho, L., Papanicolas, I., Motivating provision of high quality care: it is not all about the money (2019) BMJ, 366, p. l5210; Wagner, Z., Asiimwe, J.B., Levine, D.I., When financial incentives backfire: evidence from a community health worker experiment in Uganda (2020) J Dev Econ, 144, p. 102437; Scott, K., Shanker, S., Tying their hands? Institutional obstacles to the success of the ASHA community health worker programme in rural north India (2010) AIDS Care, 22 (sup2), pp. 1606-1612; Saprii, L., Richards, E., Kokho, P., Theobald, S., Community health workers in rural India: analysing the opportunities and challenges Accredited Social Health Activists (ASHAs) face in realising their multiple roles (2015) Hum Resour Health, 13 (1), p. 95; (2019) Malang District population and administration. In, , Malang, Indonesia, Malang District BPS; Patel, A., Praveen, D., Maharani, A., Oceandy, D., Pilad, Q., Kohli, M.P.S., Sujarwoto, S., Tampubolon, G., Association of multifaceted mobile technology–enabled primary care intervention with cardiovascular disease risk management in rural Indonesia (2019) JAMA Cardiol, 4 (10), pp. 978-986; Perry, H.B., (2020) Health for the people: national community health worker programs from Afghanistan to Zimbabwe: USAID; (2012) Posbindu NCDs guidelines, , Ministry of Health, Jakarta; Mpembeni, R.N.M., Bhatnagar, A., LeFevre, A., Chitama, D., Urassa, D.P., Kilewo, C., Mdee, R.M., George, A., Motivation and satisfaction among community health workers in Morogoro Region, Tanzania: nuanced needs and varied ambitions (2015) Hum Resour Health, 13 (1), p. 44; Borghi, J., Lohmann, J., Dale, E., Meheus, F., Goudge, J., Oboirien, K., Kuwawenaruwa, A., How to do (or not to do).. Measuring health worker motivation in surveys in low- and middle-income countries (2018) Health Policy Plan, 33 (2), pp. 192-203; Lohmann, J., Souares, A., Tiendrebéogo, J., Houlfort, N., Robyn, P.J., Somda, S.M.A., De Allegri, M., Measuring health workers’ motivation composition: validation of a scale based on Self-Determination Theory in Burkina Faso (2017) Hum Resour Health, 15 (1), p. 33; Prytherch, H., Leshabari, M.T., Wiskow, C., Aninanya, G.A., Kakoko, D.C., Kagone, M., Burghardt, J., Sauerborn, R., The challenges of developing an instrument to assess health provider motivation at primary care level in rural Burkina Faso, Ghana and Tanzania (2012) Glob Health Action, 5, pp. 1-18; Pawson, R., Greenhalgh, T., Harvey, G., Walshe, K., Realist review–a new method of systematic review designed for complex policy interventions (2005) J Health Serv Res Policy, 10, pp. 21-34; Ballard, M., Montgomery, P., Systematic review of interventions for improving the performance of community health workers in low-income and middle-income countries (2017) BMJ Open, 7 (10); Bait, B.R., Rah, J.H., Roshita, A., Amaheka, R., Chrisnadarmani, V., Lino, M.R., Community engagement to manage acute malnutrition: implementation research in Kupang district (2019) Indonesia Bull World Health Organ, 97 (9), pp. 597-604; Tumbelaka, P., Limato, R., Nasir, S., Syafruddin, D., Ormel, H., Ahmed, R., Analysis of Indonesia’s community health volunteers (kader) as maternal health promoters in the community integrated health service (Posyandu) following health promotion training (2018) International Journal Of Community Medicine And Public Health, 5 (3); (2012) Company-Community Partnerships for Health in Indonesia: Revitalizing Posyandus in Indonesia to Improve Maternal and Child Health. Indonesia: ACCESS Health Worldwide; Ashraf, N., Bandiera, O., Jack, B.K., No margin, no mission? A field experiment on incentives for public service delivery (2014) J Public Econ, 120, pp. 1-17

Indexed by Scopus

Leave a Comment